I am on the downhill side of being involved in another “beauty pageant” of my ministry life. Frankly, I’m sick of them, and it’s time to make some observations on it.
What is a beauty pageant in ministry? Let’s say a church needs a minister. They solicit candidates. Then, they take the best ones, as determined by a board or a search committee, and bring them in for a “trial sermon”, along with an interview. At the end, all of the candidates are placed before the membership of the church for a vote. They will either hire the one who got the most votes, or ask the two who got the most votes back for a runoff. Majority rules….maybe.
Here is the danger. You have so many candidates, and so many folks who like one candidate over another, that you will never get a clear mandate, and factions develop. It becomes utter chaos, congregationalism gone amok. And if a church is already having issues, any desire for a man who can help to lead them out of their morass through sound preaching and teaching is nothing more that a pipe dream. Plus, once they hire someone, that man has no chance to succeed. He will be second-guessed, and always compared to “the one that got away”.
One church I know of basically descended into anarchy when they couldn’t decide between the candidates they had called in and decided to solicit more candidates. They finally found somebody. God be with them.
We in America are so endeared with “democracy” that we cherish it over everything, including the Word of God. The only thing that even remotely comes close to such a process is the choosing of what we believe were the first deacons of the church at Jerusalem (Acts 6). Nowhere in the Bible is found mass democracy. We do, however, find evidences of godly, gifted leaders praying and asking for God’s guidance in the selection of people to help in the proclamation of the Gospel (e.g., Paul and Barnabus).
The church also is not a business. We are not hiring for a cashier on the midnight shift. if it is in a “business”, it is in th e”business” of proclaiming the Gospel and doing what it can to bring as many people as possible into a justifying knowledge of the truth. This involves a different paradigm; namely, taking the same message we are charged with proclaiming, and using it to govern the activities of the church. And that Word tells me that elders (Acts 14:23, Titus 1:5)govern the activities of the church.
It all comes down to this: whose church is it? It’s not “his” or “hers” church; it’s not Brother so-and-so’s church; it sure isn’t mine. It is the LORD’S church! And what He says matters rather than what we think we want. And God did not desire the selection of his messengers to be a popularity contest. If you look at redemptive history, there weren’t too many of those.
But you say, “Ah! God didn’t give a specific plan to select a minister.” You’re right. God didn’t tell us exactly how. But, the thought of going off into your own thing is dangerous. How do you think the Roman Catholics came up with their system? They didn’t pay attention to God’s desires and design. The results are obvious.
Whatever happened to allowing those ordained to oversee the flock to pray, research, and interview the candidate, then present them to the congregation to either affirm or deny? The elders do what they are supposed to do – oversee the flock to which they are entrusted. There is no mob rule, and there is a congregation united. And…..That is why having a plurality of elders is so important to any New Testament church. Without qualified men, desirous of the work, anarchy can ensue.
I’ve never been a fan of beauty pageants – of no sort. And there is no place for them in the Lord’s church.
‘Nuff said.